|
|
|
|
                     FILE UI CLAIM |
|
Statistics on Appeals and Decisions -- 2009These statistics reflect case processing by LIRC in calendar year 2009. Persons with questions about the statistics in any of these categories are encouraged to contact LIRC. [1995 Statistics] - [1996 Statistics] - [1997 Statistics] - [1998 Statistics] - [1999 Statistics][2000 Statistics] - [2001 Statistics] - [2002 Statistics] - [2003 Statistics] - [2004 Statistics][2005 Statistics] - [2006 Statistics] - [2007 Statistics] - [2008 Statistics] - [2010 Statistics][2011 Statistics]
[1995 Statistics] - [1996 Statistics] - [1997 Statistics] - [1998 Statistics] - [1999 Statistics][2000 Statistics] - [2001 Statistics] - [2002 Statistics] - [2003 Statistics] - [2004 Statistics][2005 Statistics] - [2006 Statistics] - [2007 Statistics] - [2008 Statistics] - [2010 Statistics][2011 Statistics]
UNEMPLOYMENT INSURANCE (2009) (1) 2009 - NUMBER OF UI APPEALS FILED AND DECISIONS ISSUED: Appeals Decisions
Filed Issued
January 182 246
February 229 185
March 285 242
April 312 237
May 285 228
June 338 186
July 285 281
August 240 196
September 204 215
October 238 235
November 243 198
December 294 231
Year 3,135 2,680 786* cases
pending at
261/mo. 223/mo. end of year
*Includes all programs (UCFX, EB, EUC, etc.) but not multi-claimant cases
[Table of Contents] - [LIRC Home Page ]
(2) 2009 - UI DECISIONS ISSUED BY TYPE OF APPELLANT: Total Claimant Appeals 1,918
Reversed in Favor of Claimant-Appellant 162/1,918 8.5%
Total Employer Appeals 755
Reversed in Favor of Employer-Appellant 59/755 7.8%
Total Department Appeals 7
Reversed in Favor of Department-Appellant 5/7 71.5%
72% of LIRC appeals were by Claimants
28% of LIRC appeals were by Employers
less than 1% of LIRC appeals were by Dept. of Workforce Development
[Table of Contents] - [LIRC Home Page ] (3) 2009 - UI TIME LAPSE STATISTICS (TIME TAKEN TO ISSUE DECISIONS) Decisions within within Over
Issued 45 Days 75 Days 75 Days
January 246 79 - 32% 207 - 84% 39 - 16%
February 185 104 - 56% 168 - 91% 17 - 9%
March 242 194 - 80% 226 - 93% 16 - 7%
April 237 192 - 81% 221 - 93% 16 - 7%
May 228 97 - 43% 215 - 94% 13 - 6%
June 186 73 - 39% 158 - 85% 28 - 15%
July 281 94 - 33% 193 - 69% 88 - 31%
August 196 36 - 18% 76 - 39% 120 - 61%
September 215 36 - 17% 53 - 25% 162 - 75%
October 235 27 - 11% 42 - 18% 193 - 82%
November 198 23 - 12% 33 - 17% 165 - 83%
December 231 27 - 12% 59 - 26% 172 - 74%
Year 2,680 982 - 37% 1,651 - 62% 1,029 - 38%
U. S. Department of Labor "time lapse" standard, effective April 1, 2008, is for average age of pending cases not to exceed 40 days. 2009 - UI CASE AGING STATISTICS
Average age of Median
pending cases
January 36 29
February 30 19
March 29 22
April 28 23
May 33 31
June 39 34
July 44 38
August 50 47
September 56 56
October 56 53
November 56 48
December 56 49
Yearly Average 43 37
[Table of Contents] - [LIRC Home Page ] WORKERS COMPENSATION (2009) (1) 2009 - NUMBER OF WC APPEALS FILED AND DECISIONS ISSUED:
Appeals Decisions
Received Issued
January 30 26
February 23 19
March 17 24
April 23 19
May 8 22
June 19 22
July 28 24
August 27 13
September 27 37
October 12 12
November 16 17
December 21 18
Total 251 253 84 Pending at
End of Year
21/mo. 21/mo.
[Table of Contents] - [LIRC Home Page ] (2) 2009 -- WC DECISIONS ISSUED BY TYPE OF APPELLANT: TOTAL APPEALS 253 Total Applicant Appeals 113 (45% of all appeals)
Affirmed (includes modifications) 69/113 - 61%
Affirmed in part/Reversed in part 9/113 - 8%
Reversed 14/113 - 12%
Remand for Approval of Compromise 4/113 - 4%
Dismissed/late petition 2/113 - 2%
Remand for New Findings & Order 2/113 - 2%
Dismissed/no jurisdiction 8/113 - 7%
Remand/Other 1/113 - 1%
Petition withdrawn 3/113 - 3%
Dismissed with prejudice 1/113 - 1%
Total Respondent Appeals 126 (50% of all appeals)
Affirmed (includes modifications) 88/126 - 70%
Affirmed in part/Reversed in part 4/126 - 3%
Reversed 7/126 - 6%
Remand for Approval of Compromise 20/126 - 16%
Remand/Other 2/126 - 2%
Petition Withdrawn 5/126 - 4%
Applicant & Respondent Appeals 14 (6% of all appeals)
Affirmed (includes modifications) 6/14 - 43%
Affirmed in part/Reversed in part 5/14 - 36%
Reversed 1/14 - 7%
Remand for Approval of Compromise 2/14 - 14%
NOTE: Because percentages are rounded some totals may exceed 100% [Table of Contents] - [LIRC Home Page ] EQUAL RIGHTS (2009) (1) 2009 - NUMBER OF ER APPEALS FILED AND DECISIONS ISSUED: Appeals Decisions Received Issued January 6 14 February 12 7 March 7 6 April 8 6 May 10 8 June 7 4 July 13 4 August 10 8 September 10 10 October 17 4 November 7 7 Pending December 11 10 End of Year 118 88 94 10/mo. 7/mo. [Table of Contents] - [LIRC Home Page ] (2) 2009 - ER DECISIONS BY TYPE, RESULT, AND ISSUE: Type of Decision Number (%) Affirmed 57 65%
Reversed 3 3%
Aff'd in part/Rev'd in part 1 1%
Aff'd in part/Remand in part 1 1%
Reversed & Remanded 2 2%
Remanded 6 7%
Dismissed (late petition) 7 8%
Settled/Withdrawn 11 13%
Total 88 Results: 42% of all decisions issued found no discrimination
9% of all decisions issued found discrimination
49% of all decisions were settlements, withdrawals,
dismissals, or procedural decisions where no
determination of discrimination was made by the
commission.
Issue: EMPLOYMENT Retaliation 31 Race 22 Sex 22 Handicap/Disability 21 Age 14 Arrest/Conviction 12 Color 6 National Origin 3 Sexual Orientation 2 Creed 1 Ancestry 1 Marital Status 1 Religion 1 Use of lawful products 1 Color of Child 1 PUBLIC ACCOMMODATION 4
(Some complaints involve more than one issue.) [Table of Contents] - [LIRC Home Page ] (3) 2009 - ER TIME LAPSE STATISTICS (TIME TAKEN TO ISSUE DECISIONS) Total
Decisions Within 90-180 180-365 Over
Issued 90 Days Days Days 365 days
January 14 1 - 7% 6 - 43% 6 - 43% 1 - 7%
February 7 1 - 14% 3 - 43% 2 - 29% 1 - 14%
March 6 2 - 33% 2 - 33% 2 - 33% 0 - 0%
April 6 1 - 17% 0 - 0% 5 - 83% 0 - 0%
May 8 2 - 25% 5 - 63% 0 - 0% 1 - 13%
June 4 3 - 75% 0 - 0% 1 - 25% 0 - 0%
July 4 1 - 25% 1 - 25% 2 - 50% 0 - 0%
August 8 3 - 38% 1 - 13% 1 - 13% 3 - 38%
September 10 4 - 40% 2 - 20% 2 - 20% 2 - 20%
October 4 1 - 25% 0 - 0% 2 - 50% 1 - 25%
November 7 3 - 43% 2 - 29% 1 - 14% 1 - 14%
December 10 3 - 30% 0 - 0% 4 - 40% 3 - 30%
88 25 - 28% 22 - 25% 28 - 32% 13 - 15%
[Table of Contents] - [LIRC Home Page ] EMPLOYER TAX OR LIABILITY ("Status") CASES (2009) Appeals received 17 Decisions issued 17 DECISIONS ISSUED, BY RESULT Affirmed* 13 - 76% Reversed 3 - 18% Remand 1 - 6% * Affirmances may include commission affirmances of ALJ dismissals of late requests for hearing. [Table of Contents] - [LIRC Home Page ] COURT STATISTICS (2009) 2009 -- UNEMPLOYMENT INSURANCE (UI) COURT DECISIONS
Total UI Court Decisions 89
Circuit Court 83
Court of Appeals 5
Supreme Court 1
Circuit Court Decisions 83
Affirmed LIRC 41 - 49%
Reversed LIRC 2 - 2%
Remand to LIRC 3 - 3%
Dismissed 37 - 45%
Court of Appeals Decisions 5
Affirmed Cir.Court, Affirmed LIRC 3 - 60%
Dismissed 2 - 40%
Supreme Court Decisions 1
Petition denied 1 - 100%
[Table of Contents] - [LIRC Home Page ] 2009 -- UI EMPLOYER TAX OR LIABILITY ("STATUS") COURT DECISIONS Total Employer Tax or Liability Court Decisions 5
Circuit Court 5
Circuit Court Decisions 5
Affirmed LIRC 2 - 40%
Remanded to LIRC 1 - 20%
Dismissed 2 - 40%
[Table of Contents] - [LIRC Home Page ]
2009 -- WORKERS COMPENSATION COURT DECISIONS Total WC Court Decisions 48
Circuit Court 36
Court of Appeals 10
Supreme Court 2
Circuit Court Decisions 36
Affirmed LIRC 27 - 75%
Reversed 2 - 6%
Aff'd in part/Rev'd in part 1 - 3%
Remand 3 - 8%
Dismissed 3 - 8%
Court of Appeals Decisions 10
Aff'd Cir.Court, Aff'd LIRC 8 - 80%
Rev'd Cir.Court, Aff'd LIRC 1 - 10%
Rev'd Cir.Court, Rev'd LIRC 1 - 10%
Supreme Court Decisions 2
Petition Denied 2 - 100%
[Table of Contents] - [LIRC Home Page ] 2009 -- EQUAL RIGHTS COURT DECISIONS Total ER Court Decisions 16
Circuit Court 14
Court of Appeals 1
Supreme Court 1
Circuit Court Decisions 14
Affirmed LIRC 9 - 64%
Dismissed 3 - 21%
Reversed/Remanded 1 - 7%
Settled 1 - 7%
Court of Appeals Decisions 1 Aff'd Cir.Court, Aff'd LIRC 1 - 100% Supreme Court 1
Petition Denied 1 - 100%
[Table of Contents] - [LIRC Home Page ] GENERAL (2009) APPEALS TO LIRC AS PERCENTAGE OF ALJ DECISIONS ISSUED ALJ Decisions Appeals
Program Issued to LIRC (%)
UNEMPLOYMENT INSURANCE 23,978 3,135 13%
EMPLOYER TAX OR LIABILITY CASES 239 17 7%
WORKERS COMPENSATION 631 251 40%
EQUAL RIGHTS 330* 118 36%
*Includes Fair Employment and Public Accommodation cases. Housing and Family & Medical Leave cases are not appealable to LIRC. [Table of Contents] - [LIRC Home Page ] COMPARISONS BETWEEN YEARS AND PROGRAMS - UNEMPLOYMENT INSURANCE Appeals Decisions Appeals
Received Issued to Court %
1989 2,194 1,916 87 4.6%
1990 2,880 2,633 42 1.6%
1991 3,286 3,250 76 2.3%
1992 3,426 3,194 83 2.6%
1993 3,582 3,656 90 2.5%
1994 3,098 3,346 74 2.2%
1995 2,509 2,704 77 2.9%
1996 2,466 2,413 53 2.2%
1997 2,427 2,316 60 2.6%
1998 2,378 2,363 48 2.0%
1999 2,152 2,243 40 1.8%
2000 2,034 2,054 50 2.4%
2001 2,462 2,383 49 2.1%
2002 3,133 2,806 65 2.3%
2003 3,985 3,200 57 1.8%
2004 3,473 4,327 58 1.3%
2005 2,613 2,845 84 3.0%
2006 2,305 2,303 71 3.1%
2007 2,313 2,251 47 2.1%
2008 2,475 2,473 60 2.4%
2009 3,135 2,680 92 3.4%
COMPARISONS BETWEEN YEARS AND PROGRAMS - STATUS (EMPLOYER TAX OR LIABILITY) Appeals Decisions Appeals
Received Issued to Court %
1989 100 118 29 25%
1990 78 82 15 18%
1991 91 78 11 14%
1992 114 93 18 19%
1993 105 114 26 23%
1994 96 132 24 18%
1995 49 62 10 16%
1996 33 42 7 17%
1997 24 24 1 4%
1998 24 27 4 15%
1999 39 35 5 14%
2000 22 31 0 0%
2001 28 35 3 9%
2002 17 17 3 18%
2003 17 30 3 10%
2004 22 19 3 16%
2005 17 29 4 14%
2006 20 17 5 29%
2007 36 30 5 17%
2008 18 31 4 13%
2009 17 17 5 29%
COMPARISONS BETWEEN YEARS AND PROGRAMS - WORKERS COMPENSATION Appeals Decisions Appeals
Received Issued to Court %
1989 543 485 97 20%
1990 587 478 84 18%
1991 620 625 87 14%
1992 655 685 134 20%
1993 587 571 119 21%
1994 502 669 143 21%
1995 502 495 97 20%
1996 559 553 91 16%
1997 502 493 85 17%
1998 491 495 73 15%
1999 406 483 93 19%
2000 412 405 60 15%
2001 388 399 56 14%
2002 413 379 55 15%
2003 346 337 54 16%
2004 361 332 55 17%
2005 290 455 76 17%
2006 250 282 37 13%
2007 304 263 38 14%
2008 275 306 60 20%
2009 251 253 42 17%
COMPARISONS BETWEEN YEARS AND PROGRAMS - EQUAL RIGHTS Appeals Decisions Appeals
Received Issued to Court %
1989 78 71 19 27%
1990 128 92 14 15%
1991 121 119 18 15%
1992 103 113 22 19%
1993 116 115 28 24%
1994 136 152 25 16%
1995 145 148 32 22%
1996 102 131 23 18%
1997 145 119 16 13%
1998 96 98 16 16%
1999 79 88 15 17%
2000 119 91 13 14%
2001 89 112 15 13%
2002 97 74 18 24%
2003 120 108 16 15%
2004 97 101 24 24%
2005 104 144 23 16%
2006 96 91 17 19%
2007 101 85 12 14%
2008 96 101 16 16%
2009 118 88 10 11%
[Table of Contents] - [LIRC Home Page ]
|
 |
  |
|
|
|
||
|
This page was last updated June 20, 2012 . |
Please direct questions or comments about this website to David B. Nance.
|
